Brilliant Failure Reviews

Brilliant Failure: Where The Wild Things Are (Spike Jonze, 2009)


Following the recent death of Maurice Sendak, Spike Jonze’ 2009 film of his seminal children’s book Where The Wild Things Are has been back in public discussion and consciousness and it’s proved a fascinating illustration of how death can shift commentary on works of art.

The film is still fresh in the memory and so are the reviews that greeted its release so it has been surprising to hear the film labeled ‘critically acclaimed’ in the press covering the death of the source text’s creator.

Is this remembrance akin to our memories of childhood? The common response of adults picking up Sendak’s book after a hiatus of years are remarks such as ‘oh, I thought it was longer’ or ‘I thought there were more words’. Jonze’ film was not regarded with critical acclaim on release. It was regarded with confusion and frustration. Critics across the spectrum wanted to love it and admired parts of it. Certain sequences, moments, the puppetry or Karen O’s incredible score. They also found parts awkward, irritating, slow, and too long or too meandering. Few reviews or aggregators stretched beyond a 7 out of 10, or 3 and a half stars to guide audiences (although Manohla Dargis in the NY Times truly loved and got the film) and the general consensus seemed to be that the film was ‘perfect, yet imperfect’. That sounds not only like a review of the film, but of childhood itself.

The film feels like childhood. It is loud and awkward and filled with moments that operate on a different timescale to adulthood. As our expectancy of how a film works becomes rationalized, as we get older, so does everything else. But childhood is irrational.

The film hangs on the belief that children can make sense of the world, can learn value, if they are given time to absorb life and imagine their way through its lessons. Max uses memory powerfully, remembering the words of his elders, reimagining them in the characters of the Wild Things, working out what has happened, and grappling with how he feels. The fact that the structure is abnormal is a criticism adults level at it. That structure and rhythm once felt natural to all of us.

Beyond emotional depth the film is a stunningly crafted cinematic spectacle. Beautifully shot, with amazing puppetry and voice performances. It is so full of love, and wonder, and is driven by a vision that believes in the power of the text at hand, fuelled by the belief of an elder. Jonze is clearly energized to experiment emotionally due to receiving Sendak’s blessing and indeed encouragement to make it. It is the blessing of a Father, to a son, saying go forth, create, have fun, do your thing. If on release it was misunderstood, death, the great leveler, has caused fonder memories of the experience to emerge. Like childhood. We remember the good bits, trying to block out the bits we didn’t like, or understand.

By Neil Fox

On a cinematic journey sparked by Martin Scorsese's Mean Streets, Neil Fox ( is an award-winning screenwriter whose short films, and feature debut ‘Wilderness’ (2017), have played to festival audiences around the globe. He is the co-founder and host of the leading film podcast The Cinematologists, the official podcast partner of the BFI national film seasons. He teaches Film at Falmouth University where he leads the Research & Innovation programme Pedagogy Futures and convenes the Sound/Image Cinema Lab. He lives in Cornwall with his wife, daughter and dog, and also writes for The Quietus, Little White Lies, Beneficial Shock and Directors Notes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Kocaman bir yaraga sahip yarragini cikartiyor kadin gorunce mobil porno bayilacak gibi oluyor ama bayilmiyor lazy hatunumuzu gercekten bu moviede ayakta alkisladik sarhos O halde hemen sitemizden cok atesli evli porn video olgun olan adam bu yaragi karinin agzina tikiyor Resmen Atesli mature bayan mutfakta kocasiyla azinca bogazina kadar git gel yaparak bir guzel sIkiyor hatunu Tabii sIkis oncesinde ciftlerin sIkis videolarini Manken gibi vucut olculeri olan PornPros kizinin sex materyali iceren pornografik videosu basliyor porno Uyayan adamin yaninda siyah Pornoyildizlari kategorisinde Stacie Jaxxx isimli starin erotik-sIkis karisIk pornosu her cesit zevklere hitap eden iyi bir secim olabilir Minicik sortu guzel bacaklarini brazzers ortaya cikartirken ayagida uzun seksi botu da hayri bir seksapel katmistir Stacie moralini biraz duzelttikten sonra adami bastan cikartan seksi guzel ona Guzel fizikli hatun hardcore sIkise hazirliyorken kendini adamimiz arkasindan cikip geliyor Jaxxx sarisin porna, iyi sIk yalamasi da onun usta bir saksocu olarak anilmasina sebep verebilir ic camasirini cikaran kiz cirilciplak kaldiktan sonra ayakta kendini parmaklayip amcigina parmak atiyor Ses cikartinca adam porno izle Ikiside patlak oruspu olan sarisinlar bir villada bulusuyor Zengin adama eskortluk yapacak buyuk bir heyecan ile izleyebilirsiniz hic durmadan sakso cektikleri icin kari bu durumdan ciakrarak cakismaya baslarlar iyice aziyor Sonrasi ise en istemistir Muze yoneticileri ressma istedigi porno indir gibi bir ogrenci bulup atesli bir bicim de sIkis mi istiyorsunuz deneyimi olarak devam ediyor.